I'm the One Who Said Do It": Trump Claims the Alaska Lawsuit as America's Election Fight Heads to Court
"I'm the One Who Said Do It": Trump Claims the Alaska Lawsuit as America's Election Fight Heads to Court
Ten days before Americans vote in the midterm elections, the United States Justice Department has gone to court to try to stop Alaska from certifying the result of its Senate race if the Republican incumbent loses narrowly. President Donald Trump on Friday publicly claimed the lawsuit as his own idea, telling reporters, "I'm the one who said do it." The case, filed in federal court in Anchorage, turns on an unusual fact: two men named Dan Sullivan are on the ballot, and the government argues voters could confuse them.
The lawsuit is the most aggressive pre-emptive election challenge of this campaign so far. Republicans hold narrow majorities in both chambers of Congress, and Alaska — a state Trump won by a double-digit margin in 2024 — is hosting a close Senate contest between incumbent Republican Senator Dan S. Sullivan and Democrat Mary Peltola. Voting-rights groups filed a motion on Friday asking a judge to throw the case out and even to consider sanctions against the lawyers who brought it.
What the lawsuit actually asks for
Filed on Thursday, the Justice Department's complaint names the state of Alaska and local election officials as defendants. It asks a federal judge to block certification of any result "that may be impacted by voter confusion," so that investigators can determine whether votes cast for the second Sullivan were meant for the senator.
The second candidate is Daniel J. Sullivan, described in reporting as an independent candidate and a retired teacher from Petersburg, Alaska, listed on the ballot without a party label. The Justice Department alleges he entered the race "with the intention of misleading supporters of Senator Sullivan into voting for him." A department spokesperson said the agency was taking "necessary steps to ensure that this frivolous candidacy does not undermine the integrity of Alaska's election or the will of its voters."
The complaint's logic rests on Alaska's ranked-choice voting system, under which voters rank candidates in order of preference. The government argues there is a substantial likelihood that the presence of a second Sullivan on the ballot will confuse people trying to vote for the incumbent, and that certifying a result affected by that confusion would reflect a process that lacked integrity. It asks the court to hold off certification to allow an investigation into voter intent — a remedy that, critics note, is extraordinary before a single ballot has been counted.
Daniel J. Sullivan has denied being connected to Democrats. According to reporting on the case, he has said he is running because he is dissatisfied with the incumbent's record. Alaska's Supreme Court previously allowed him to remain on the ballot after election officials tried to remove him, which means the question of his candidacy has already been litigated in state court — a point the challengers are expected to press.
Why Alaska matters so much
Alaska is not usually the centre of American election drama. It is a Republican-leaning state, and Senator Sullivan is seeking re-election in a state his party expects to hold. But the 2026 midterms, which will be held on 3 November, will decide control of Congress, and a single Senate seat can matter enormously when majorities are narrow.
That arithmetic is what makes the pre-emptive nature of the lawsuit so striking. Rather than waiting for results, the federal government is asking a court to intervene in advance, on the basis of a result that has not yet happened. Legal experts quoted in US media have described the case as legally dubious, noting that ballot names are normally settled long before election day.
The lawsuit also fits a broader pattern of federal election oversight under this administration. The Justice Department has pressed states for voter-registration data, argued that stricter measures are needed to ensure public confidence in the vote, and — in a parallel move reported on Friday — ordered California counties to identify suspected non-citizens on voter rolls and set aside their mail-in ballots, warning of criminal liability for officials who knowingly count ineligible votes. Supporters of these steps say they protect election integrity. Critics, including Democratic and some Republican election officials, view them as federal overreach into elections that the US Constitution leaves largely to the states.
The pushback: "frivolous" and unconstitutional?
The response came fast. On Friday, two Alaska voters, the League of Women Voters of Alaska and the voting-rights group Common Cause filed a motion asking the court to dismiss the Justice Department's lawsuit. Their argument, as reported, is that the federal government is claiming excessive authority over elections administered by individual states, that the case lacks a sound legal basis, and that granting the department's request could disenfranchise voters and undermine their fundamental right to vote.
The motion also asks the court to consider sanctions against the government attorneys who filed the case, describing the lawsuit as frivolous and unsupported by the National Voter Registration Act. It cites President Trump's own remarks to a reporter on Friday as evidence of political pressure behind the case — the president's "I'm the one who said do it" comment, made while he was travelling in Florida, is now part of the court record in the challengers' filing.
That detail matters for readers in Britain as well as America. In the UK, elections are run centrally by the Electoral Commission and local returning officers, and the idea of a government minister directing a lawsuit to block certification of a result before polling day would be constitutionally unthinkable. In the US, elections are decentralised by design, which is precisely why a federal lawsuit of this kind is so contested: it tests where federal power ends and state authority begins.
Senator Sullivan's campaign has said it will let the complaint proceed, while adding that Alaskans can tell the candidates apart. Alaska election officials have said they are reviewing the lawsuit and remain focused on running the election. Peltola, the Democratic challenger, has criticised the federal intervention.
What happens next
Three questions will decide what this case means. First, will the Anchorage federal judge act before election day, or let voting and counting proceed and deal with any challenge afterwards? A pre-election ruling blocking certification would be unprecedented in its scope; a decision to wait would deflate much of the lawsuit's immediate force.
Second, will the case become a template? Democrats and voting-rights groups fear the administration is preparing to intervene in other close races, pointing to the California ballot letters issued the same week. If the Alaska theory — that a confusing ballot justifies holding up certification — gains traction in court, it could be invoked elsewhere.
Third, what do Alaska voters do? Early voting is under way in many states, and record early-vote figures suggest a highly engaged electorate. If either candidate wins comfortably, the confusion argument loses its force. If the race is decided by fewer votes than Daniel J. Sullivan receives, expect this case to become the defining legal fight of the 2026 midterms — and a test, watched far beyond Alaska, of how far a president can go to shape the rules of his own party's re-election.

Comments