California Voters Reject Proposition 40 Billionaire Tax After $379 Million Campaign

California Proposition 40 billionaire tax ballot Sacramento Capitol

California voters have rejected Proposition 40, the ballot measure that would have imposed a one-time 5 percent tax on the state's billionaires. The Associated Press called the race on Monday, nearly a week after polling day on November 3, with 52.8 percent voting no and 47.2 percent voting yes.

It was the most expensive ballot fight in California history, and one of the most closely watched votes in the country this year. The measure would have created the nation's first wealth tax. Instead, it lost by about 621,000 votes, with roughly 83 percent of the expected vote counted — 5,909,778 against and 5,288,379 in favour. The results remain unofficial until the California Secretary of State certifies them on December 11.

Proposition 40 would have applied to Californians whose net worth topped $1 billion and who were residents of the state on January 1, 2026 — about 200 people. The tax, equal to 5 percent of their net worth, would have been due in 2027, with an option to spread payment over five years at additional cost. Backers estimated it could have raised about $100 billion over five years, with most of the money going to Medi-Cal, the state's Medicaid programme, and other healthcare services.

A campaign fought with wildly uneven money

The spending gap was the story of the campaign as much as the tax itself. Opponents spent $378.4 million against the measure, led by $102 million from Google co-founder Sergey Brin. The yes campaign raised $33.5 million. The no side, in other words, outspent supporters by more than ten to one.

That money paid for months of television, mail and online advertising arguing the tax would drive billionaires — and the jobs and tax revenue that come with them — out of California. Supporters, led by the healthcare workers' union SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West, which put the measure on the ballot, argued the state needed the money to protect healthcare from federal budget cuts, and that 200 people could afford a one-time charge on fortunes built in California.

The polls moved against the measure as the campaign wore on. An October survey by U.C. Berkeley's Institute of Governmental Studies found 50 percent of likely voters opposed it — up from 48 percent in August — with 42 percent in favour. A separate October poll by the Public Policy Institute of California found 52 percent opposed and 46 percent in favour. By election night, the result was already clear: Proposition 40 trailed from the first returns.

The split inside the Democratic Party

What made the vote unusual was who lined up on each side. The state Democratic Party backed Proposition 40, and Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont and Representative Ro Khanna of California campaigned for it. But Governor Gavin Newsom opposed the tax, arguing billionaires would find ways to avoid it or leave the state, and that a national tax on the wealthy would be a better approach.

Newsom's opposition gave cover to Democrats who were uneasy about the measure, and it split the party's establishment from its labour base in public. The governor's argument — that a state wealth tax would be hard to collect and easy to escape — was echoed in much of the no campaign's advertising, which warned that the tax would fall hardest not on billionaires themselves but on the companies and workers tied to them.

Geography told its own story. San Francisco, home to many of the tech fortunes the tax would have hit, backed the measure by roughly 56 percent to 44 percent. Statewide, it lost by more than five points. The measure's supporters had hoped California's progressive reputation would carry it; instead, voters in most of the state sided with the governor's caution.

What the defeat changes — and what it doesn't

Two companion measures were designed to cancel Proposition 40 out. Proposition 42, which would bar any new wealth tax in California, was ahead by 51.6 percent to 48.3 percent with about the same share of the vote counted, though it had not yet been called. Proposition 41 would also have restricted the state's ability to impose wealth taxes. If either passes with more votes than Proposition 40, the tax would have been nullified even if it had won — a belt-and-braces strategy by its opponents.

The defeat does not end the argument. The AP reported that backers said they could put a similar tax back on the ballot in 2028. And the problem Proposition 40 was meant to solve has not gone away: Medi-Cal faces pressure from federal cuts, and California's budget still leans heavily on a small number of very wealthy taxpayers. Our explainer on what a government shutdown is and what actually closes covers the federal funding fight that is squeezing state budgets from the other direction.

The result also lands in a changed political landscape. Democrats swept both chambers of Congress in last week's midterms, and the new majorities arrive in January ready to fight over taxes and spending at the federal level. California's vote suggests that even in the country's most Democratic large state, a wealth tax is a harder sell than its supporters expected — especially when the other side can spend $379 million saying so. Our earlier story on Trump naming Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff covers the reshuffle in Washington as both parties prepare for the fights ahead.

For now, the 200 or so Californians worth more than $1 billion will not be getting a tax bill in 2027. The healthcare programmes the tax would have funded will have to find their money somewhere else.

Sources

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sir Patrick Stewart Dies at 86: Star Trek's Captain Picard and X-Men's Professor X Remembered

"Healey's £20 Billion Bet: Chancellor Arms Britain's State Banks to Back AI, Defence and Green Energy"