California Death Row Commutation Faces Court Fight as Prosecutors Vow to Challenge Newsom's Order
California Governor Gavin Newsom announced on Thursday that he is commuting the death sentences of all 548 people on the state's death row, converting each one to life in prison without the possibility of parole. It is the largest mass commutation in American history, and it effectively empties the biggest death row in the United States — one that holds roughly a quarter of all condemned prisoners nationwide. But the order is far from final. Most of the commutations, 382 of them, still need the approval of the California Supreme Court, and prosecutors across the state have promised to challenge the decision in court, setting up a legal fight that could run for months.
Newsom, who declared a moratorium on executions shortly after taking office in 2019, announced the decision two days after the midterm elections. In an open letter to Californians, he wrote that he firmly believes "state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California's values, undermines the foundations of our legal system, and diminishes each of us." His office said restitution orders imposed on the prisoners remain in place; only the death sentences are wiped away.
Most commutations need the state Supreme Court's approval
Under California's constitution, a governor cannot commute the sentence of a person convicted of more than one felony unless the state Supreme Court recommends it, with at least four of the court's seven justices concurring. According to the governor's office, 382 of the 548 prisoners fall into that category. The remaining 166 commutations Newsom can grant on his own authority.
Newsom acknowledged the burden his filing places on the court. "While I am confident this act of categorical clemency is consistent with California law, I acknowledge that my decision to exercise my constitutional clemency authority requires the Justices to participate in a weighty decision they did not choose to take up and with which they may personally disagree," he wrote. His office has asked the justices to review each case on its own merits and to hear from victims' family members. The court faces practical complications as well: it is currently missing a seventh justice, with one seat vacant for about a year, and it has no established mechanism for considering a single request covering 548 people at once, according to legal reporting by Law.com. The state Supreme Court's press office had no comment.
Prosecutors promise a legal challenge
The backlash from law enforcement was immediate. Anne Marie Schubert, a former Sacramento County district attorney who now leads the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, said her organisation intends to challenge the commutations before the California Supreme Court, arguing that victims' families were never consulted. "There's going to be a number of arguments that we will make, but at the end of the day, we are doing this on behalf of crime victims and the rule of law," she said.
Greg Totten of the California District Attorneys Association said the commutation process "was never intended to serve as a substitute for the legislative process or to allow one elected official to effectively nullify hundreds of jury verdicts simply because he disagrees with the law." Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman noted that while commuting sentences is within the governor's power, abolishing the death penalty is a decision for voters — who rejected abolition ballot measures in 2012 and 2016. "Until the law is changed, my office will continue to evaluate every death penalty-eligible case with the rigor, care and restraint these decisions demand," Hochman said. Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer also criticised the order, and prosecutors in several counties publicly highlighted the victims of the condemned, including Marc Klaas, whose 12-year-old daughter Polly was murdered in 1993 by Richard Allen Davis, one of the men whose sentence Newsom commuted.
Supporters call it a historic step
Civil liberties and anti-death-penalty groups praised the decision. The Legal Defense Fund noted that Newsom's order is the largest reduction in the U.S. death row population since the Supreme Court's 1972 Furman v. Georgia decision. Anthony D. Romero, executive director of the ACLU, said the commutations reflect "an end to a racist, error-prone, and inhumane punishment." Some prosecutors agreed with Newsom: Contra Costa District Attorney Diana Becton said commuting the sentences "will save California taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars over the long term."
The decision also drew support from some victims' relatives. "I used to think the man who killed my sister deserved execution," said Jess Nichol, sister of Polly Klaas. "But over time I've realized that whether he's executed has absolutely nothing to do with my recovery or with real public safety."
California's death row holds 529 men and 19 women, according to state corrections data, and includes serial killers such as Randy Kraft and Charles Ng. The state has executed 13 people since 1976, and its last execution was about 20 years ago. Only five people received death sentences in 2025, down from 42 in 1999, and 68 percent of those under sentence of death are people of colour, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. The announcement also landed amid renewed national scrutiny of capital punishment following Tennessee's failed execution of Christa Pike in late September.
Why it matters: what happens next
The fight ahead is unusual because of the California Supreme Court's double role. The same court that must recommend 382 of the commutations may also be asked to rule on the prosecutors' legal challenge to the whole order — judging a process in which it is itself a required participant. The arithmetic is tight: four justices must concur in each recommendation, and the court currently has only six sitting members because of the year-long vacancy.
Timing matters too. Newsom is term-limited and in the final stretch of his governorship, so a slow review could push hundreds of individual decisions past the end of his tenure, leaving the process to be completed — or contested — under his successor. His request that justices review every case on its own merits, and hear from victims' families, points to months of hearings rather than a single ruling.
Finally, it is worth being precise about what Thursday did and did not change. The death penalty remains California law: voters have twice voted to keep it, and district attorneys such as Hochman say they will continue to consider it in new cases. What changed is the fate of 548 specific people — and whether that change survives now depends less on the governor who signed it than on the court that did not ask for it.
Sources
- CNN — Newsom commutes sentences of all California death row prisoners
- USA Today — Newsom commutes California death sentences for 548 people
- Law.com — Gov. Newsom Throws Mass Death Penalty Commutation Review to Calif. Supreme Court
- The Desert Sun — Most of Newsom's death row commutations need court approval
- NAACP Legal Defense Fund — Statement on the commutations

Comments